Michelle Shelburne, founder of Sanctuary Indy

Our Founder’s Story

Michelle Shelburne

Michelle has always found herself unable to look away from our city’s “literally” homeless. She has worked several years for a Veteran service provider, serving those who are either homeless or imminently at risk of becoming homeless. She is also a member of the Indianapolis Continuum of Care, a Coordinated Entry System Skilled Assessor for the CoC, and canvasses the eastside of Indianapolis each week doing street outreach.

Since her childhood days in the Bay Area of California, Michelle has always been moved to help those sitting on a sidewalk feebly holding a sign for help. For over 20 years, she has worked in many capacities with those struggling with homelessness, from leading an organization for at-risk young adults to helping nomadic “travelers” with needed resources for addictions, food, and shelter – even spending weeks living with them in the Ocala Forest of Florida, as they escaped from our world they call “Babylon”.

Her deepest desire for change with our homeless came from what she experienced after walking alongside a dear family member who endured mental illness that led to months of homelessness. She was utterly shocked by the lack of access to attainable help for those compromised by their health and financial resources. Although there are providers in Central Indiana to help our homeless, they are not easy to find if you don’t know where to search. In addition, the timeframe of help is dismal.

In early 2020, while doing outreach at an encampment on a cold and clammy February day, Michelle briefly met Tina, a very nice older lady sitting by a campfire. Although over 60 years old, she had been living outside for over four years, struggling with both mental health and substance use disorder. As they parted, Tina affectionately stated “It was nice to meet you, Michelle.” A week later, Tina had passed away. Michelle couldn’t grasp how we as Hoosiers could continually allow that to happen. It left a deep mark on her heart, as she cried for someone she had only spent a few precious moments with. An elderly individual living four years outside in Indiana’s elements. Why? How? In Indianapolis!

This is where the fire was lit to fill the gap, through Sanctuary Indy.

Meet Our Founding Team

(from left to right)

Michelle Shelburne

Founder / President

Mary Ann Beale

Treasurer

April Vail

Vice President

Angela Cahoon

Secretary / Advancement Director

Team Bios

April Vail

Vice President

Hoosier native April Vail relocated to Indianapolis in 2014, after embarking on a career change and receiving her Bachelor’s in Public Affairs (BSPA) at the IU Bloomington campus. She now serves professionally at a local Veterans organization as a Permanent Supportive Housing case manager. With over a decade of experience serving people experiencing homelessness, April sees Sanctuary Indy as a solution that fills a gap in our community. April joined the Sanctuary Indy board in March 2022 and currently serves as our Vice President.

Mary Ann Beale

Treasurer

Mary Ann has worked in the banking and business management fields for more than 35 years. Since her return to Indianapolis in 1992, she has served several communities through food and clothing pantries. Mary Ann helped launch a relational ministry supporting a subculture of young adults through mentorship, relationship, and connecting them to resources. She later served on their board. She also served on a board that helps high school students grow in their faith. Mary Ann is Sanctuary’s board Treasurer.

Angela Cahoon

Secretary / Advancement Director

Ange moved to Indianapolis in 2005 after completing her Master's in Nonprofit and Public Management at the IU School of Public and Environmental Affairs (now the O’Neil School) in Bloomington, Indiana. Her career in fundraising has focused on education and poverty alleviation. Ange has served as an active community volunteer with The Villages, North United Methodist Church, The Oaks Academy, and now Sanctuary Indy as our Secretary and Advancement chair. Trained in trauma-informed care as a foster parent in 2012, a decade later, she continues to use a trauma perspective to create safe spaces for mental health healing.

Additional Board Members

  • Heather Bennett

  • Cody Walburn

  • Theresa Patterson

  • Brandon Wallace

  • David Price